Fans of superheroes , hard - boiled investigator , and sci - fi who do of historic period in the thirties through the seventies were habituate to asking stock proprietor where they stocked theircomics . And if they go across a fellow enthusiast , they ’d inevitably ask which comics they picked up every workweek . It was n’t until the eighties and the rise of prestige title like 1986’sThe Dark Knight ReturnsandWatchmenthat the phrasegraphic novelentered the lexicon . reader used it to denote their feeling that comedian were more substantive than non - lector might trust ; those same non - readers uttered the term with a sniff of disdain , as though cartoon strip lover were simply trying to dress up their hobby with more sophisticated language . The term was sometimes even used in quotes , as though people were not quite sure what to make of it .
So what ’s the actual difference between comic books and graphic novels ? Are these terms similar , or does each own identifying characteristic ?
funny books are , of course , recognizable as periodicals issued on a unconstipated basis that feature consecutive graphics . Theearliestexamples of American comic strip date back to the twenties , when newspaper strips likeMutt and JeffandJoe Palookawere collected and reissue . By the 1930s , comic strip started to featureoriginal fabric , and presently became the medium of pick for the burgeoning superhero musical genre and resembling the offspring we see on shelves today .
In 1964 , a funnies buff named Richard Kyleusedthe termsgraphic storyandgraphic novelin an clause about the futurity of the comics culture medium for a fanzine , or self - published fan powder magazine . Kyle and another fan , Bill Spicer , later issued a fanzine titledGraphic Story Magazinein what was probable an attempt to modernize the medium and perhaps yield it a high level of believability . That may have been made more difficult by the 1966 television unveiling of ABC’sBatman , which embrace the DC character ’s kitschy aspects and submit comics as perceived juvenilia for decades to hail .
The termgraphic novelwas used only sporadically through the 1970s and former 1980s . In 1971 , DC Comics declaredThe Sinister House of Secret Love#2 and its 39 - page level a " graphic novel of gothic terror ” on the effect ’s concealment . In 1976 , creative person Richard Corben’sBloodstar , a 104 - Thomas Nelson Page phantasy comic establish on the work of Conan creator Robert E. Howard , declareditself a graphical novel on the book ’s flap . So didA Contract with God , a 1978 piece of work by comics legendWill Eisner . There was a clear association being made between length and terminology , with long works increasingly being labeledgraphic novels .
In the other eighties , Marvel beganreleasinga line of graphic novel likeThe Death of Captain Marvelthat were big than the intermediate comic , with a heftier price shred of $ 4.95 . The titles were representative of the increase trend toward cartoon strip wrapped in more elaborate packaging . In a 1983 profile of Atlanta artist Rod Whigham and his 111 - page work , Lightrunner , the termgraphic novelwas prescientlydescribedby Science Fiction and Mystery Bookstore owner Mark Stevens : " A graphic novel is like a comic al-Qur’an but much longer , " he said . " The formatting is enceinte , ordinarily hold fast and the story has a definite ending . ”
The term was also embraced by Mort Walker , the Almighty of the laughable stripBeetle Bailey , whopublishedtwo graphic novels sport the beleaguered Army soldier in 1984 . The books , FriendsandToo Many Sergeants , were all - new consecutive art stories , not reprints of the strip . Walker mention European graphic novels as inspiration , say that comics readers oversea suffered less of a mark than domesticated readers . " Businessmen , for representative , commuters get going to work , are not embarrassed to read graphical novel on the caravan , ” he said .
Because of the history of graphic novels having more reputed content than exclusive - consequence strip , the musical phrase took off in the eighties , when DC published deal paperback collections ofWatchmenandThe Dark Knight Returns . Alan Moore , the author ofWatchmen , laterobservedthatgraphic novelcaught on with marketing departments . " You could just about callMausa novel , you could just about callWatchmena novel , in terms of density , structure , sizing , scale leaf , seriousness of theme , stuff like that , ” he said . " The trouble is that ' graphic novel ' just come to mean ‘ expensive comic book of account ’ and so what you ’d get is mass like DC Comics or Marvel Comics , because graphical novels were getting some attention , they ’d beat six return of whatever worthless bit of dogshit they happened to be publishing lately under a calendered cover charge and call itThe She - Hulk Graphic Novel , you live ? ”
This protracted history is where we likely find the true detachment between comics and graphic novels . By and big , comic books are periodicals . They are published regularly and in an economic data formatting , page staple together . Often , a laughable book can not put up on its own as a complete narrative . It builds off what has occur in issues before it .
A graphic novel , on the other hand , tends to be substantially longer than an average comedian ’s 22 page and tells a largely self - arrest story . grant toBonecreator Jeff Smith , the graphic novel has a beginning , middle , and terminate , with minuscule of the ephemeral tone of a comic and its electrostatic characters . The packaging is typically more full-bodied , with factual binding and better newspaper publisher or color reproduction quality . By merit of the fact it ’s collecting an on-going narrative from a comics series — bothWatchmenandThe Dark Knight Returnswere first sold as individual issues — or tell an original story , it offers some conclusiveness . And while people may look more substantial thematic or narrative geographic expedition than they would in a comic , it could still conceivably be , as Moore asserts , a despicable slice of crap .
Owing to this subjectivity , it ’s hard to sayThe Dark Knight Returnsis not a comic book , although it might be a reach to call a undivided issue ofHoward the Ducka lifelike novel . That term might be well earmark for title that provide a plentiful storytelling experience with a definitive closing . Or we could harmonise with Moore , who considers the difference minimal . " The term ‘ comic ’ does just as well for me , ” he said .
If you ’re on the hunt forcomic book gift musical theme , you may also want to take a feeling at our natural endowment templet .
Have you got aBig Questionyou’d like us to answer ? If so , send it tobigquestions@mentalfloss.com .
A version of this clause was originally publish in 2019 and has been updated for 2022 .
